A personal loan in Canada is usually an unsecured instalment loan: a fixed amount, a fixed rate, a fixed term and no collateral. Average pricing sits near 10.95%, while the prime rate lenders price from is 4.95%. That gap says most of the spread comes from the borrower's file rather than the market. Federal law also caps the criminal interest rate at 35% APR, so anything quoted above that line is either a regulated payday product or a warning sign.
Your credit score is the first filter. Canadian scores run from 300 to 900, calculated from files held by Equifax and TransUnion, and the best bank pricing tends to start around 680. Below 650, you drift into the alternative lender market, and that gap is expensive. A $15,000 loan over five years costs roughly $3,470 in interest at 8.5% and about $10,860 at 24% — same money, same term, three times the cost.
Where you live is the second filter, and it matters more than most borrowers expect. Ontario and British Columbia cap payday borrowing at $15 per $100; Manitoba and Saskatchewan at $17. Quebec takes a harder line and caps all consumer lending at 35% APR, which is why payday storefronts barely exist there. The federal criminal rate applies everywhere, but the small-dollar products around it differ from province to province — and so do the disclosure rules, the complaint process and the regulator you can call when something goes wrong.
Third: the shape of your local economy. Household debt remains high relative to disposable income, and credit card balances have climbed past $130 billion nationally, with delinquency rates rising faster than wages. In the GTA and the Lower Mainland, rent eats the budget before a loan payment is even considered. In Alberta, income tied to the energy sector makes some lenders nervous about seasonal swings. In rural Atlantic Canada, a branch may be forty minutes away, which pushes borrowers online whether or not that is the cheaper choice.
Banks, credit unions and online lenders compared
Comfort with your own bank is not the same as a competitive offer. Rate shopping across three lender types takes an afternoon and routinely saves four figures.
| Lender type | Examples | Typical rate range | Typical loan size | Strongest for | Watch for |
|---|
| Big Five banks | RBC, TD, BMO, Scotiabank, CIBC | 7.99%–11.99% | $1,500–$35,000 | Existing customers with scores above 680 | Some banks cap terms at five years; approvals move slowly |
| Other banks | National Bank, Desjardins, EQ Bank | 7.49%–12.99% | Varies by product | Borrowers outside the Big Five | Eligibility is often tied to holding an account |
| Credit unions | Vancity, Meridian, Servus | 7.99%–13.99% | Varies by member | Members with steady but uneven income | A membership share is usually required |
| Online prime lenders | Borrowell, Mogo, Loans Canada | 9.99%–19.99% | Often smaller amounts | Fast decisions, thin credit files | You pay more than a bank would charge the same profile |
| Alternative lenders | Fairstone, easyfinancial | 19.99%–32% | Smaller amounts | Scores under 650, urgent cash | Interest over the term can approach the principal |
Banks reward relationships and provable income. Credit unions tend to be the middle path for people whose income does not fit a tidy pay-stub template — contract workers, farm operators, anyone whose earnings arrive in lumps. Online lenders win on speed, sometimes funding the same day, and that matters when a transmission fails on a Tuesday and the dealership wants a deposit by Friday.
Two details matter more than the advertised rate. Ask for the total cost of borrowing in writing, because that figure includes fees and any optional creditor insurance that quietly finds its way into the quote. Then ask about prepayment penalties: a loan with none lets you clear the balance early and cut the interest bill.
Two borrowers, two different outcomes
Sarah, a dental hygienist in Brampton, carried $19,000 across three cards and was paying close to 21% on the largest balance. She walked into her credit union with two years of statements and left with a three-year loan at roughly half her card rate, payments on autopay. Her file was not perfect. The membership officer looked at twelve months of on-time rent and utility payments instead.
Kyle runs equipment near Saskatoon. He needed $12,000 in a slow quarter and had been quoted a rate built on the assumption of a salaried job. A local credit union reviewed two years of farm income rather than one pay stub, priced the loan lower and set the payment date after harvest. Neither borrower found the cheapest advertised rate in the country. Both found a lender that read their file correctly.
A twenty-minute checklist before you sign
Order your reports from Equifax and TransUnion and read them line by line. Wrong addresses and accounts you never opened are common, and a single error can push a file out of the best pricing tier.
Get written quotes from a bank, a credit union and one online lender in the same week, then compare total cost of borrowing rather than the headline rate. A 9% loan with a mandatory insurance premium is not cheaper than an 11% loan without one.
Run the payment against your real budget, not your hopeful one. If rent, utilities and the new payment leave nothing for groceries, the term is too short and the amount too high.
Take the shortest term you can genuinely afford. Stretching from three years to seven lowers the monthly figure and raises the total interest substantially.
Treat a loan as a tool for one-time costs and consolidation, not a fix for a monthly shortfall. Debt consolidation that clears cards you then refill has solved nothing; it has only moved the balance.
Where to find help
The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada publishes plain-language material on cost of borrowing disclosure. Provincial regulators such as the FSRA in Ontario and the BCFSA in British Columbia handle complaints about licensed lenders, and Quebec's consumer protection office is the contact point for lending disputes there.
If the numbers do not work, non-profit credit counsellors and Licensed Insolvency Trustees can walk you through consumer proposals and debt management plans. That first conversation is usually confidential and low pressure. A bad credit file does not leave you with one door; sometimes a repayment plan is the cheaper one.
Two quotes, one afternoon, a written total cost for each. That comparison is the whole game, and the difference between them often covers a year of car insurance or a plane ticket home. Pull your reports this week, then ask two lenders what they would actually charge you — not what their website advertises.
研究の知恵